Jacques Mauritain Explains The Teleological Argument


Some time ago, I picked up a book at Capitol Hill Books (I can’t remember whether it was filed under theology or philosophy) on existentialist theologians (the cover design, for all you fans of those Masterpiece Mystery title sequences, is by Edward Gorey). It began with Jacques Mauritain.

I first came across his name in a book my father got my some two decades ago called Inventing the Middle Ages, a fascinating work of historiography (which also led me to read The Waning of the Middle Ages by Huizinga and a couple of others).

Mauritain was a dedicated Thomist for most of his intellectual life. Now, I can’t pretend to have read much by Aquinas and I understood not all of what little I read (though I’ve read plenty about his writings, so I understand the basics, unless everyone I’ve read who wrote about Aquinas was lying to me).

Anyway, he (we’re back to talking about Mauritain) puts a nice spin on Aquinas’ teleology, making it far more palatable.

If, like me, you were taught about Aquinas spin on Aristotle’s ‘unmoved mover,’ you were probably less than impressed. Purely philosophically, I don’t think I’m generating controversy by saying that it’s lacking.

But Mauritain is looking at things as more of a hybrid theologian/philosopher (I don’t mean that he was necessarily trained or studied theology; but that hybrid role could, perhaps, could be said of all philosophers who come at their studies from a specifically religious-minded position; also, this rather suggests that if the book wasn’t filed under theology, maybe it should have been, except the theology section is a lot more Purpose Driven Life and a lot less I and Thou). He comes at his teleological argument implicitly tolling the primacy of faith. For him, likely as it was for Saint Thomas, the ‘unmoved mover’ is not so much a way to ‘prove’ the existence of God as it a way to create a means for fellow men of faith to improve their understanding of God; not by truly ‘understanding’ God (impossible, surely?), but by rather by providing a framework to understand one’s relation to God.

Midweek Staff Meeting


They also have a great collection of Pre-Raphaelite paintings.

Benjamin’s afterlife.

What are we supposed to have learned from the Dead Sea Scrolls?

Chief Justice William Rehnquist: An unreconstructed, hypocritical, pill popping racist or a left handed albino Eskimo pipe welder?

Stand Up To Hurricane Induced Power Outages


Use a typewriter.

Saturday Post – President Heidegger


Goes straight after John Ashberry, doesn’t he?

What if Heidegger had become leader of Germany?

The ultimate in existentialist blogging.

The myth of the ‘Liberal Media.’

Pacifica Radio Archives


I couldn’t help it. I donated $50 to the Pacifica Radio Archives.

They are trying to digitize all the old reel to reel and cassette tapes before the disintegrate.

They were playing clips of Ray Bradbury speeches and interviews. It was kind of a science fiction hour, and one of the hosts talked about the tape of an interview he did with A.E. Van Vogt (not so long ago, I tracked down a copy of his Weapon Shops of Isher, having read as a teenager a short story that was actually an excerpt from it).

So, I had to do my part to preserve those records.

WTF?!


Really? My home state of Florida, under the guidance of Rick Scott and his Republican ouija board, is now dissing both my college major (history) and my minor (philosophy)?

Governor Rick Scott, you lack the basic self control God gave to an infant monkey suffering from projectile diarrhea, you ignorant c–p weasel.

You are an amazing combination of ignorant and embarrassing. Congressman David Rivera (R-soon to be indicted, just lost) is five seconds away from looking at you and saying, ‘Dude, you have lost the plot.’

Ugh.

Worldly Philosophers


Worldly Philosophers is a famed attempt to make economics sexy. Mainly by skipping out of the math (which is cool by me; Warrant: The Current Debate had way too much math for my liking).

Author Robert L. Heilbroner, despite being an avowed socialist (or was for most of his career), wrote this passage, which absolutely infuriated me:

[Sir William Petty] was observing a fact that can still be remarked among the unindustrialized peoples of the world: a raw working force, unused to wagework, uncomfortable in factory life, unschooled to the idea of an ever-rising standard of living, will not work harder if wages rise; it will simply take more time off. The idea of gain, the idea that each working person not only may, but should, strive to better his or her material lot, is an idea that was quite foreign…”

Firstly, that whole passage reeks of colonial-minded paternalism.

And also, how is it that greater leisure time is not also part of an “ever-rising standard of living?”

It has been noted that those envy-inspiring images of Austrians conversing over coffee in the caffe’s of Vienna or of the French enjoying long lunches and leisurely glasses of wine are not a result of uniquely gallic or tuetonic culture. Or at least not how we usually think of it.

It’s about time. It’s about a culture that does not believe a people should have to work 60+ hours a week to support themselves and their families. Germans and even the Japanese, despite myths to the contrary, work fewer hours than Americans. When you have an extra three hundred and sixty hours a year (as the average German worker does), you can spend more time with family and enjoy leisurely activities.

I want to thank Heilbroner for introducing me to Thorstein Veblen (even his name is awesome! and descriptions of him washing his dishes with a garden hose aimed at the sink and showing up at his justifiably estranged wife’s door with a pair of socks are hilarious in a sad way), but I’m still fuming about that remark (which actually occurs very early in the book – before he even gets to Adam Smith).

Midweek Staff Meeting – A Poet’s History


The great broken menhir of Locmariaker, with Cæsar’s table

Gary Snyder through the years.

Canadian poets have not died out (yet).

A travel book about Brooklyn lit (not really, but kind of).

Cool megalithic stuff. I’m serious.

Happy Birthday, Virgil


The poet who brought us The Flea and Georgics would have been 2082 today.

Eugene Genovese Died. Really? Why Did No One Tell Me?


I don’t think I’d seen this before, but apparently, Eugene Genovese died late last month.

That’s a real bummer. He was a Marxist and sometimes leftist (don’t make the mistake of thinking Marxist thought is necessarily leftist) historian of the American South and of slavery in the American South. Even when he became, in some ways, more conservative (he became quite infatuated with the Southern Agrarians), he never stopped seeing the influence of class structures on society.

Anyway… Roll, Jordan, Roll: The World the Slaves Made. I had to read it in college. It’s awesome. You should read it, too.